(Just couldn’t resist that classic Allen joke in the title there)
You know the drill, Dear Reader: a birthday rolls around, and your humble narrator dedicates a blog post in your honor. Not a bad deal, really. This edition’s victim is none other than my older brother, Brady.
Let it begin!
My first memory of Brady, for some reason, occurs as I stand outside the front door of our old house. I’m looking down into the driveway, where an almost unnervingly focused teenager with messy black hair throws a worn-out basketball at a hoop. There’s nothing really to this memory, and I don’t know why my brain has clung to it over the years, but such is the nature of having older siblings. You find yourself simply gawking at them, whether you’d like to admit it or not, studying their every move like a language you just barely can’t speak.
Brady is about nine years older than me, and that presented a weird situation as I grew up: he was too old to be a playmate, and too young to be a parent. Who was this guy to me? I think I spent at least a few of my earliest years just trying to figure that out, but whoever he was, I wanted to be like him. I learned quickly that he was apparently “strong.” I learned this because he told me. And even though I nodded many assertions, Brady would always appraise me skeptically after I had been informed, certain that I didn’t quite get the message. He would then begin a very relaxed stroll in my direction, which always reminded me of those bad guys in horror movies who don’t run because they know they don’t need to. When he invariably caught me (and to be honest I hit a period where I would just throw in the towel out of fear), I endured a series of physical torments whose scientific classification is “a whooping.” I lived my young life in a constant orbit around whoopings, I was either coming from or going towards one all the time. As I got older and more opinionated, Brady began repurposing them as some kind of corrective mechanism for my attitude. I would make a smart comment to mom at the dinner table, and he would lean forward over his plate and advise me with a smirk, “You need a whooping, son.”
For years I detested this, and took it kind of personally. A less artsy kid probably would have rolled with it sooner, but I was built by the Lord to be sensitive and touchy-feely, so a guy who more than doubled my weight hanging me upside down over a body of water got old fast. One day, I submitted one of my many tattle-tale reports on this behavior to mom, who had initially intervened when I was younger but slowly began leaving me to handle it. She listened sympathetically, but stopped me when I declared something along the lines of, “I don’t understand why he doesn’t like me.” Her face was very troubled.
“Doesn’t like you? What are you talking about? Your brother loves you!”
Technically, I knew this, but when you’re that young, you’re still not sure what love really means. “I guess.”
“Honey, Brady loves you to death, that’s just his way of showing it.”
This revelation left me stupefied. I never looked at Brady the same way again. The next time he came after me, I still ran and begged for mercy, but when I would laugh, he laughed back. It also suddenly dawned on me that there was a laundry list of things he never did: he never punched me (not once), never slapped me or threw me into anything, never insulted me, didn’t inflict any real pain ever. Because he put on such an elaborate, theatrical performance, I never stopped to consider the fact that I always, no matter what, got right up from a whooping and ran along my merry way. From that day on, I began to think of this ritual as a kind of performance: I had my role to play (it wasn’t as fun if I didn’t still run and screech for help), he had his, but I never felt even remotely unsafe, and my feelings never got hurt. Because what mom said proved to be right (as usual): Brady loved me.
The dynamic of our relationship shifted after that. Once my behavior started signaling to my brother that I understood what he was really saying, I think he and I became friends in a way we couldn’t have been otherwise. He would take me fishing with him, or play basketball with me, talk to me about things that were happening in his life, listen to stories about mine, give advice and encouragement. I played along carefully, but I never got over being starstruck around him; he was always bigger and stronger, always seemed in control. When I would panic, he would focus, and where I was constantly running from responsibility, he was always embracing it. I formed an embarrassingly large amount of my personality and worldview around his example, and much of that remains to this day.
On top of that, Brady also gave me an enormous gift: the ability to conquer myself. He knew I was a little spoiled, that it would be all too easy for me to stick to my safe zones and go stagnant as a man. Not on his watch. He would push me to do things I was afraid of, and he never let me back down no matter how much I begged him. He put me on roller coasters, mopeds, jet skis, high dives, water slides, sleds, and wild animals, and I fought him every step of the way. If I cried or put on a big show, he would sigh impatiently and demand, “You’re fine.” He refused to go easy on me, because I think he felt that doing so would be an insult, would suggest that maybe I couldn’t handle my fear, and he believed I could. “Suck it up,” “Don’t think about it,” “Just give it a try.” He had to push me pretty hard sometimes, but once I had done it, he was always there at the other end like nothing happened “Wasn’t that great?” I would get so excited, jumping up and down and declaring, “I did it! I did it!”
But Brady, incredible guy that he is, never once seemed surprised. He would grin and shrug, “Of course you did. It was nothing.” The consistency of his belief in me, his stubborn insistence that I could be strong and brave and do things on my own, was and is one of the best things anyone has ever done for me. I will never really be able to pay him back for it. I get incredible satisfaction watching him engage Jacob in the exact same way (it’s different with girls), although I am happy to report that the J-Man seems to be learning faster than I did.
By the time I was well into high school, my brother had a family of his own to worry about, and I knew that he could no longer devote the same attention to me. I realized that Brady was a father by nature, a man who lives to shepherd the ones he loves, and while I had benefited from that quality for years, now I had to let it go. I have never stopped missing it. There was one final lesson that I think he imparted to me, albeit a kind of strange one. One night I convinced him to watch “The Matrix Revolutions” with me (back when I was convinced it was good), certain that I could secure and relish his approval. After all, if Brady liked a movie, that was the highest stamp of honor I could imagine. So we watched it, and when the credits rolled he smirked and stated matter-of-factly: “That was not great.” I was destroyed by this, how could I be so stupid as to think this movie was good, when clearly he saw that it was not? Here I had been acting like his equal, and all along I was just a dumb kid again. My feelings were indescribably hurt and as I recall we got into some kind of argument. Brady walked away.
A few minutes later, he came back and said something I’ve never forgotten:
“Rew, I’m really sorry, buddy. I don’t…you have to understand that movies don’t matter to me like they do to you. I just watch them, and I enjoy them or I don’t. But you’re not like that, you love them, you know a lot more about them, and they’re part of who you are. Sometimes it’s just hard for me to understand that.”
No one had ever really taken the time to spell that out for me, and when he did I realized that I had lived my whole life somehow unaware of it (I really am not that bright). After that, Brady started connecting with me by showing me movies, especially R-rated ones that mom and dad would allow on the grounds of his supervision. He introduced me to Scorsese, Coppola, Spielberg, “Swingers,” “The Usual Suspects,” films and filmmakers that remain in my highest esteem to this day. But this was only the surface of what he was doing. He was also, in a very quiet way, reminding me of something very important: You are different from me, and that is okay. You can’t mimic me in every way, because it wouldn’t make you happy or successful. You can do things I can’t, and you should embrace that. You have to be you. I’ve spent my life emulating my brother, but in the end I think all he’s ever wanted was for me to be myself. The more I do things my own way, the prouder and more supportive he seems to be. He never hesitates to point out how he admires my skill at writing, or public speaking, or film making, or music. But thanks in no small part to his influence, I don’t really need him to point those things out anymore. I know who I am and I’m proud of it, and I owe the dude a beer for that.
Happy Birthday, Brady. I’m sure you know this, but you’re still my hero.