In honor of Caroline’s birthday, I’ve decided to devote this entry on the blog to some of my fondest memories of my big sister. They are listed in no particular order, just things that occur to me as I look back in my memory. I’ve been known to remember things with a slightly different perspective than HooGirl, so maybe she will contest some of my mental authorship here, but with that in mind, let us move forward!
-The first thing I always remember is when Caroline and I were at the lake house (sniffle sniffle, I miss that lake), and I was holding her out over the edge of the water by her lifejacket strap. We were standing on a firm but slippery wooden dock, and my sister was attempting something that I can’t really remember now. She was leaning all the way over, dangling precariously above the flat, cool embrace of Smith Mountain Lake, with only my hand to keep her safe. Of course, I let go. In the single moment before she impacted the smooth surface of the water, she had time to shout one thing: “IAN!”
In a moment of panic and frustration, I became indistinguishable in her mind from her close friend and my frequent partner in crime, Ian Weise. I only bring this story up because it demonstrates my sister’s strange preference for surrounding herself with troublesome, immature people (no offense Ian), in spite of the fact that she herself is legendary for her restraint and maturity. I think the reason she does this is because Caroline has one thing in common with us scoundrels: mischievousness. She loves to affectionately tease and harass her loved ones, always searching for clever, or at least utterly confusing, ways to do so. I remember one night on a family cruise, Caroline snatched Brady and Holly’s room service order from their doorknob and added 12 rounds of prune juice. You could practically hear the bafflement from down the hall the next morning.
-Speaking of the cruise, I also remember being forced to pose as my sister’s boyfriend when she got the urge to go dancing at night. I always thought this was an overreaction, until I slipped away to use the restroom and came back to find her cornered into a booth by three different would-be suitors. I shouldn’t need to explain the point of that story.
-Every Allen knows a simple rule of life: you do not play “Monopoly” with Caroline. You don’t do it, it’s punishment from God. I’ll never forget the look on her face as she sat across the board from me on the orange carpet in our basement, counting the hefty load of flimsy, Monopoly-money she had just extracted from me through a verbal agreement to give her ownership of the railroads. My plan had been to appease her with this trade, and then when I needed Park Place, which she would invariably land on and have no use for, she would be receptive to an agreement. Two or three turns later, she did indeed acquire this property, but my confident, almost lazy assurance that we could come to an “understanding” was met with a stone-faced “No thank you.”
What? “But…but I traded with you!”
“So?”
Mom, of course, cut in and attempted to make her daughter negotiate, but my mother’s fanatical desire to see all of her children do equally well at everything borders on Communism, and Caroline wasn’t having it. She wasn’t rude, or even forceful, just…firm. A few turns later, I acquired St. James Place, which my sister greatly desired in order to complete the L-shaped “Death Alley” of hotels she was setting up on her side of the board. She offered a trade, and I really savored laughing uproariously at her, but the way that she shrugged off my refusal bothered me. After I wiped the tears of joy from my eyes, she looked…unbothered.
“What were you going to trade for it?” I asked nonchalantly.
She shrugged.
“Tell me.”
“It doesn’t matter now, you don’t want to trade.”
“No, I know, I’m just wondering.”
“Why would I tell you?”
“What does it matter?”
“Exactly, so let’s move on.”
“Was it something good?”
Caroline smiled wickedly, “Oh yeah.”
“What was it?”
“Your turn, mom.”
“No! C’mon, Caroline! Just tell me!”
Ten minutes later, I found myself agreeing to a trade of St. James Place for the “mystery box.” I’m not going to recite to you how that happened, because I myself do not remember. No Allen can tell you how Caroline acquires a thing from you, she just gets it. She never yells, never gets emotional; trying to fight her is like arguing with gravity. Caroline Allen is simply a master tactician, a cunning manipulator, always playing the Chess game of life two moves ahead of you.
Oh, by the way, the “mystery box” was a dollar.
-I’m sure she doesn’t remember this, but once Caroline and I were walking along a beach when I was very young, somewhere around 10. Most older sisters would be obsessed with ignoring and persecuting a brother this much her junior, but Caroline is a person with an enormous heart, and she took upon herself the responsibility of helping to steer young “Rew” in the right direction whenever it was necessary. I don’t remember what we were talking about, but I specifically recall that it was about my life, and all the ridiculous interpersonal conflicts that an elementary school student spends time mulling over.
Of course, Caroline knew that because I was a young boy, I looked more towards my father and older brother as role models, and her advice, though infinitely wise and carefully constructed, was sometimes unfairly discarded. So as I continued to rant, she must have had some idea that her response was not being eagerly anticipated, but she forgave this and waited for her moment anyway. I was half-way through condemning an old friend as a permanently wasted human being, doomed to an entire life of idiocy and annoying-ness (as young boys do), when Caroline cleared her throat to make a statement.
“In the real world, Andrew, things are usually not black and white.”
Even at that age, the response stunned me. I know her answer seems trite, but it wasn’t. The Devil knows no better shield to prevent the digestion of truth than to make it a cliche, but the tone of my sister’s voice, the look in her eyes, stung me deeply. Very few statements from any human being in my life have ever continued to hammer my heart and mind so rigorously. To this day, that one sentence is at war with me, pushing me to try and see every side of a thing before I talk about it.
That is Caroline’s imprint upon me as a person: emotional maturity (not that I’ve mastered it). She is the one who forced me to call into question my emotions, second-guess the things I would like so much to believe for selfish reasons, and demand the highest standard of honesty from my thoughts. So many people are content to paint the world the way they’d like to see it, but that has never been good enough for my sister. She wants to see the world as it is, and her example has been a guiding light for me ever since.
I love you, Caroline. Happy birthday!